Skip to main content

Reaction to the 2015 Emmy Nominations: Snubs and Surprises

Reaction to the 2015 Emmy Nominations: Snubs and Surprises




The Primetime Emmy nominations were announced Thursday morning, here are my thoughts on some of the big categories. 

Outstanding Comedy Series: Louie, Modern Family, Parks & Recreation, Silicon Valley, Transparent, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, Veep

The surprises here were good ones, Parks and Recreation and Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt are both terrific shows and deserved their spots. Veep, of course, is always deserving. Emmy voters were never going to deny Louie and Modern Family. Haven't seen the other two. 

Outstanding Drama Series: Better Call Saul, Downton Abbey, Game of Thrones, Homeland, House of Cards, Mad Men, Orange Is The New Black

The snubs include Empire, which I haven't seen, but many people seem to like, and Bloodline, which I liked, if not loved,  The Americans and The Good Wife. Honestly I don't think very highly of any of the shows that were nominated. 

Lead Actor in a Drama Series: Kyle Chandler, Jeff Daniels, Jon Hamm, Bob Odenkirk, Liev Schreiber, Kevin Spacey


Of all the first rate performances on Bloodline, to single out Kyle Chandler for a nomination seems a bit odd. Jeff Daniels is a bit of a surprise, but deserved for anchoring that bizarre final season of The Newsroom.

Lead Actress in a Drama Series : Claire Danes, Viola Davis, Taraji P. Henson, Tatania Maslany, Elisabeth Moss, Robin Wright

I don't get what everyone sees in Orphan Black. Maslany gives a good performance, but not exactly Emmy-worthy. Surprised not to see last year's winner Julianna Margulies or Ruth Wilson or Taylor Schilling nominated. Would have liked to see Tea Leoni get a nomination for Madam Secretary, but I knew that was a long shot. 

Lead Actress in a Limited Series or Movie: Maggie Gyllenhaal, Felicity Huffman, Jessica Lange, Queen Latifah, Frances McDormand, Emma Thompson

Another nomination for Jessica Lange? Really? Queen Latifah is the obvious choice to win, for her astonishing performance as Bessie Smith. I did see the PBS broadcast of Sweeney Todd, and I thought Thompson made a great Mrs. Lovett, so I am happy about that nomination. 

Lead Actor in a Comedy: Anthony Anderson, Louis C.K., Don Cheadle, Will Forte, Matt LeBlanc, William H. Macy, Jeffrey Tambor

Surprising to see Anderson and Forte, but they always do solid work, so I'm not complaining. LeBlanc and Macy are fantastic on really good shows.  Interestingly no Jim Parsons. 

Lead Actress in a Comedy Series : Edie Falco, Lisa Kudrow, Julia Louis Dreyfus, Amy Poehler, Amy Schumer, Lily Tomlin

By far the biggest snub of the morning is Ellie Kemper. I just do not understand. And Lily Tomlin? She's a legend, but the show is very mediocre. Would have liked to have seen Emmy Rossum or Constance Wu or Mindy Kailing or Gina Rodriguez or even Sutton Foster.

Supporting Actor In A Drama Series: Jonathan Banks, Ben Mendelsohn, Jim Carter, Peter Dinklage, Alan Cumming, Michael Kelly

Jon Voight got snubbed. I thought Norbert Leo Butz gave a little more layered performance than his Bloodline co-star Mendelsohn. 

Supporting Actress In A Drama Series: Joanne Froggatt, Lena Headey, Emilia Clarke, Christine Baranski, Christina Hendricks, Uzo Aduba

How both Sissy Spacek and  Linda Cardellini got snubbed for their extraordinary work on Bloodline is a mystery to me. I am also perplexed by Aduba's nomination. Kate Mulgrew and Lorraine Toussaint (along with Schilling in the lead category) are simply in a different league than the rest of the actors on that show. Those three women give such profound performances, it's puzzling how they were overlooked in favor of their good-for-a-web-show co-star. 

Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series: Andre Braugher, Adam Driver, Keegan-Michael Key, Ty Burrell, Tituss Burgess, Tony Hale

Hale and Burgess were both deserving. 

Supporting Actress In A Comedy Series: Mayim Bialik, Niecy Nash, Julie Bowen, Allison Janney, Kate McKinnon, Gaby Hoffmann, Jane Krakowski, Anna Chlumsky

Nash got a Timmy nomination last year for her Getting On role, so I'm glad the Emmys have finally caught up. This is a pretty good category, although I would substitute Hoffman for her co-star Judith Light. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Muppet Fan's Reaction to the Firing of Steve Whitmire and the Recasting of Kermit the Frog

By now I'm sure you have heard the news that Steve Whitmire, the longtime portrayer of Kermit the Frog (and other Muppets), has been fired after 27 years of playing the frog and 39 years of being with the group.  At first, the circumstances of Whitmire's departure from the Muppets were unclear. Whitmire later released a statement revealing that Muppet Studio executives had made the decision to recast Kermit, citing two instances as the reason for the recast; Whittier's vocal input on the creative direction of the character, and what he described as a "union issue". Disney (who owns the Muppets) then released a statement claiming Whitmire had been fired due to "unacceptable business conduct".  According to Brain Henson (who, along with his mother Jane, had handpicked Whittier to succeed his father in the role of Kermit after Jim Henson's death in 1990), Whitmire made "outrageous demands and often played brinkmanship" and commented that he s…

"Marnie" is One of Alfred Hitchcock's Most Underrated Films: Review

Classic Film Review: "Marnie" (1964)If your list of favorite Alfred Hitchcock films does not include Marnie, you need to rethink your list. The 1964 film, adapted from the novel by Winston Graham, finds the Master of Suspense and his collaborators at the top of their game. Bernard Herrman's score is equal parts grand and hypnotic. Edith Head's costumes inform as much of Marnie's character as the script does. The production design is among the best in any Hitchcock film. It's a suspenseful psychodrama that allows Hitchcock to do what he does best. When it was originally released in July 1964, the film received mixed reviews from critics, ending a hot streak for Hitchcock that included North by Northwest, Pyscho, and The Birds. In the years since its initial release, Marnie has rightly become known as one of the films that best define Hitchcock's style.
Tippi Hedren plays the titular Marnie, a thief who takes office jobs only to steal money from the company…

"Wonder Woman" is One of the Best Superhero Movies of the Last Few Years: Review

Film Review: Wonder WomanIt's baffling to me that Wonder Woman is arguably one of the three most famous superheroes in the world and yet it has taken 75 years for her to get a live action feature adaption. In the same span of time, Superman has starred in eight movies and Batman in nine. Whatever the reason for the delay, Wonder Woman has finally made it to the big screen. Wonder Woman is a sharp, funny, and high-energy origin story. Director Patty Jenkins has figured out how to have an optimistic superhero, a symbol of love, exist in a dark and destructive world without a jarring of tones.