Skip to main content

New "Twin Peaks" is a Puzzling and Maddening Experience: Review

TV Review: "Twin Peaks: The Return"

Image result for twin peaks: The return
Disclaimer: This review contains major spoilers for the original Twin Peaks and minor spoilers for Twin Peaks: The Return.

The original Twin Peaks, created by Mark Frost and David Lynch, is one of the most beloved and iconic television series of all time, despite only running for 30 episodes on ABC in 1990 and 1991.  Heavily influenced by daytime soap operas, it featured several hallmarks of that genre: a sleepy town, an ensemble of wacky characters, an ongoing mystery, and the illicit and adulterous underside of the facade of a wholesome American small town. Of course it was also more that, and as the series went on it became more of a supernatural exploration of good and evil, but the soapy trappings gave the series a shape and a structure. The highly anticipated revival miniseries, now airing on Showtime, eschews shape and structure altogether in favor a more puzzling, maddening creation.

Image result for twin peaks: The returnEver since Dallas started the trend back in 2012, many continuations of old shows have sprung up, among them Arrested Development, Gilmore Girls, and soon Will & Grace and Roseanne. These shows cash in on nostalgia for the old show, as a way to tell new stories in an already-established world. While this trend is what made Twin Peaks: The Return possible in the first place, it was clearly not the intention of Frost and Lynch to pick up where they left off in 1991. The new show is almost nothing like the old show in story, tone, or form. This time, the melodrama has been completely excised. Large portions of the first four episodes are taken up by characters we have never seen before, and very little of it actually takes place in the town of Twin Peaks. Perhaps it is not fair to judge the series based on what I personally wanted it to be, but it seems Lynch is fully aware that people were expecting a return of the old show, as short scenes with familiar characters like Dr. Jacoby (Russ Tamblyn) and Shelly Johnson (Madchen Amick) are interspersed throughout the first few episodes. This subversion of audience expectations is classic Lynch, but whether it's to the benefit of the series remains to be seen.

I will not give away too much of the plot of the new show, not because I want you all to watch it unspoiled, but rather I do not think I could describe much of what happens. To say this show is confusing is an understatement. The original Twin Peaks ended on a great cliffhanger, with Agent Dale Cooper (Kyle MacLachlan) trapped in the Black Lodge and his doppelgänger possessed by the evil spirit BOB returning to Twin Peaks. Laura Palmer (Sheryl Lee) coyly tells Cooper "I'll see you in 25 years". 26 years later, Laura returns to tell Cooper he can leave, but his doppelgänger is still out there. There is also stuff about a mysterious box in New York and a murder investigation in South Dakota, and a couple other subplots whose relevance is unclear. Lynch is not the type of director who ties together loose ends or answers half of the questions the audience has. It is fully possible that several of the mysteries introduced in the first four episodes will not even be mentioned in the remaining twelve. 

I don't mean to say that the original was perfect and this is garbage. The second season of the original series is far from perfect, as pressure from the network caused the reveal of Laura Palmer's killer to be rushed (although the imperfect prequel movie Fire Walk with Me did fill in some of the blanks regarding that storyline), and the episodes that immediate follow that resolution are pretty terrible. The last six or so episodes of the season quicken the pace and things pick up quite a bit, culminating in a stunning finale. One of the main flaws of the original is that it has a bunch of talented actors given interesting characters but no story and were hardly ever seen. Among the shortchanged were Amick's Shelly, Audrey Horne (Sherilyn Fenn), Ed Hurley (Everett McGill), and Norma Jennings (Peggy Lipton). The revival seems to have no desire to rectify past injustices, as Amick (who is also fantastic on the Twin Peaks-inspired Riverdale) is the only one make an appearance thus far, and that was just a cameo. 

Some enjoyment can be derived from the new series if you like celebrity cameos. The first four episodes rival any Muppet movie for most number of unnecessary but still welcome guest appearances. So far the guests have included Ashley Judd, Matthew Lillard, socialite Cornelia Guest, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Michael Cera (doing a bizarre Marlon Brando impression), and Naomi Watts. One part of the new series that was genuinely terrific was the phone conversations between two classic Peaks characters; Hawk (Michael Horse) and Margaret, the Log Lady (Catherine E. Coulson) , especially poignant because the scenes were filmed shortly before Coulson's 2015 death. 

I will continue to watch Twin Peaks: The Return, which airs through September, fully expecting none of my questions to be answered. Even if the experience of watching strange other worlds and abstract, incomprehensible images can be extremely challenging at times, I am taking it as a 2017 variation on the themes explored so richly on the original series. Not a continuation exactly, more like a complementary viewing experience.

What do you think of Twin Peaks: The Return? Let me know in the comments below!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Ten Best TV Shows of 2019

Best of TV 201910. BH90210 (Fox) What an unexpected delight this show was. While the original Beverly Hills, 90210 was before my time, I found plenty to enjoy in this funny and shiny reboot. The premise sees the cast playing fictionalized versions of themselves preparing to reboot the '90s teen drama that made them famous. Their willingness to poke fun at their images made for a great satire of celebrity culture. 9. The Great British Bake Off (Channel 4 in the UK, Netflix in the US)In its tenth year, this show is old news. Nothing new or surprising can be evinced from this format. So why on Earth did this season nearly bring me to tears multiple times? I don't have an explanation, I just know how it made me feel. Perhaps it had something to do with this crop of contestants, but the nicest reality competition there is made for some for most pleasant viewing experiences of the year.  8. Mrs. Fletcher (HBO) Based on the Tom Perrotta novel, Mrs. Fletcher charts a woman's journey …

Disney Review: "Pinocchio" (1940)

"Pinocchio" (1940)

Based on the children's novel "The Adventures of Pinocchio", "Pinocchio" was supposed to be Disney's big follow-up to their big hit "Snow White and the Seven Dwarves". Released in February 1940, and despite positive reviews from critics, the film was a major disappointment at the box office. Maybe this was because the film couldn't open in certain markets because of World War II, or maybe the box office returns just seemed disappointing because the unprecedented success of "Snow White..". Either way, most people wouldn't expect a film that's so well remembered today to have bombed during its initial release. But, thankfully, how "Pinocchio" preformed in 1940 has nothing to do with the quality of the film. The film was everything people expected, and more.


The Ten Best Films of 2017

Top Ten Films of 2017

10. I, TonyaYou have to hand it to Margot Robbie, who proved her acting chops and her capability as a producer with the same film. Robbie transforms her voice and her physicality in order to play infamous figure skater Tonya Harding at various stages in her life. She's never a perfect match for the real-life Harding, but she's so different from the Australian bombshell that we see on the red carpet that it's the type of performance that wins Oscars. Also fantastic in the film are Allison Janney as Harding's mother, Sebastian Stan as her ex-husband, the consistently under-appreciated Julianne Nicholson as her coach. Also featuring zippy editing and a great soundtrack, I, Tonya raises some very timely questions about classism, the media, and the nature of truth. 


9. Battle of the SexesIt was not immediately clear to me after seeing Battle of the Sexes whether or not it would end up on this list. But when it came time to for me to pick ten movies, I co…