Skip to main content

A Very Female Kind of Rage: The Women of "Sharp Objects"

See the source image

WARNING: SPOILERS FOR ALL OF SHARP OBJECTS TO FOLLOW 


Sharp Objects, the HBO miniseries based on the Gillian Flynn novel, concluded its eight-episode on Sunday night with a killer installment that included one heck of a twist ending: Amma (Eliza Scanlen) is the person responsible for the killings that Camille (Amy Adams) was sent back to Wind Gap to report on. This series was a lot of things; a slow-burn mystery, an intense character study, and depiction of self-harm, a showcase for terrific actors, a perfect vehicle for Jean-Marc Vallée's trademark dynamic editing style. And there is a lot I could say about it, but for now, I want to focus on how Flynn, Vallée, and Marti Noxon subvert expectations about the characters we think we know, and how easy it is to do so because of societal assumptions about women.

The set-up of Sharp Objects is close to perfect. Camille Preaker is a deeply damaged woman with problems with alcohol and a penchant for carving words into her body who must confront the demons of her past in order to report on a story in her hometown. Her mother, Adora Crellin, is a controlling and dominating figure, not only in Camille's life but in Wind Gap as a whole. Her half-sister, Amma, plays two roles, that of Wind Gap's popular it-girl, and that of helpless child Adora can care for. The two big reveals in the final episodes, that Adora has been poisoning her daughters in order to keep them constantly sick enough for her to take care of in a Munchausen by proxy situation that killed her other daughter Marian, and that Amma is Ann and Natalie's killer, are effective because they work against our knowledge of these specific characters and the roles they fill in society. Adora clearly loves Amma, why would she be slowly trying to kill her? Women are often portrayed as motherly caregivers, which is most commonly used to show if women are kind or virtuous enough for the audience's sympathies. This story flips that, making Adora's need to care for her daughters pathological, a symptom of a deeply toxic relationship. Her mental illness condemns her to fill her societally-prescribed role too well, to the point of having to artificially produce the conditions for her to do so. In her article, Camille describes this as "a very female kind of rage", which is fitting, as Flynn constructs Adora's crimes in a way that calls attention to a specific box woman are often placed into.

Throughout the series, people mention that Ann and Natalie's killer must be a man because "women don't kill that way". It's assumed a woman simply doesn't have the strength (or the desire) to pull teeth out of a person's mouth with pliers. They never even consider that a group of women (or girls) would be strong enough to carry out these crimes. (The only false note in the show for me is that Kelsey and Jodes, Amma's friends/accomplices, wouldn't even hint at feeling remorse for helping to commit such horrible crimes. Must the audience assume that they too are psychopaths?) Thus, the revelation that the killer is a fourteen-year-old girl is both surprising and a critique of the ways girls and women are viewed by society.

A common theme in Flynn's work is that women are more often thought of as victims rather than villains. Reversing that expectation is what makes Gone Girl so fun, but Sharp Objects is an arguably more nuanced attempt. Amma is a villain but also a victim. Years of being fed rat poison by Adora has likely messed with Amma's brain and caused her to be the narcissistic psychopath she is. The villain/victim split so well because Amma is already in two worlds as both the perfect daughter and the wild child. (Amma herself appropriately compares herself to Persephone in the final episode). The feminine style of killing of Adora directly leads to the more violent (meaning masculine) style of the killing of Amma. The genius of Sharp Objects is that it both subverts the supposed ideals of womanhood and debunks them completely.

Even the character names help corrupt notions of feminity. Amma, Adora, and Joya, Adora's cruel mother who is mentioned several times, are all uncommon names, which draws attention to them. By associating them with positive words and concepts (joy, adoration, amorous), it's all the more surprising when the characters are revealed to be very twisted and dark.

The depiction of Camille, the protagonist, as a flawed and complex individual is perhaps the most obvious example of Sharp Objects' intention to portray its female characters in ways more varied than practically anything else on television. Camille's actions are often unsympathetic and would be alienating if the series did not do so a good job at weaving her memories of pain and grief into her current situations. Her self-destructive tendencies make her kind of bad at her job, and even the way she tries to save her sister in episode eight is harmful to her body. But Camille would not be as nearly interesting if she weren't the way she is. That Camille is nothing like the woman a girl who grows up in Wind Gap is supposed to be and why is given as much exploration as the murder investigation, which highlights the expectations of women that have to be at the forefront of the audience's minds in order for the twists to be shocking subversions. The intricate way these stories are woven makes Sharp Objects one of the best television series in recent memory.

Thanks for reading! Have thoughts on Sharp Objects? Leave a comment below!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The New "Charlie's Angels" Reboot Doesn't Feel Like "Charlie's Angels," For Better and Worse: Review

If you listen closely, you can hear the sound of Hollywood execs hard at work at rebooting your favorite franchise. In an age where IP is more valuable than any movie star or original idea, everything from the past will eventually get slapped with a new coat of paint and trotted out once more for the consumption of modern audiences. This week's edition: Charlie's Angels. I'm not opposed to reboots and remakes in general, but when this reboot was announced, I couldn't help but give a vaguely melancholic shrug. It really cannot be overstated how much I loved the 2000 version and its 2003 sequel as a child. My obsession with those films led to countless viewings, a love for the original 1970s TV show, and a lifelong standom of Lucy Liu, Cameron Diaz, and my all-time fav Drew Barrymore. If Hollywood so desperately wanted to squeeze new life out of this franchise, why not do a sequel to those movies and bring back Lucy, Cameron and Drew? I would have been first in line to b…

Drew Barrymore is Getting a Daytime Talk Show. Here's Why I Hate It

When Hollywood stopped making big screen romantic comedies after the '00s, there was an entire group of actresses who were forced to pivot their careers to something else. Kate Hudson, Sandra Bullock, Cameron Diaz, Jennifer Aniston, Reese, and Drew Barrymore were all members of this group. Today's news that Drew Barrymore's daytime talk show has been picked up and will premiere in fall 2020 has got me thinking about the career choices these actresses have made since the death of their genre. Reese moved into prestige vehicles on the big screen and mainly on the small screen these days. Sandra Bullock appears in far fewer movies than she did fifteen years ago, but when she does pop up it's mostly in prestige fare. Cameron Diaz retired from acting entirely. Kate Hudson, well I already wrote a thing about what Kate Hudson did. Nearly all of these women have started lifestyle brands or companies, following in the footsteps of the Empress of Celebrity Lifestyle Brands, Gwyn…

Best of TV 2016

The Ten Best TV Shows of 2016Here are the best televisions of 2016:

10. Stranger Things (Netflix)

 The Netflix series quickly became a pop culture phenomenon when it launched on the streaming site in July. Starring a fantastic Winona Ryder as the mother of a missing child, the series pays homage to numerous sci-fi films from the 1980s. Good writing, smart pacing, and a satisfying level of suspense makes Stranger Things a worthwhile binge whether you get the references or not.